FIRE, DEATH, FALSE CONFESSION, AND WRONGFUL CONVICTION:
A TALE OF TWO COUNTRIES
Case Name |
Higashi Sumiyoshi Case |
Mark Kirk Case |
Defendants |
Tatsuhiro Boku(29)m Keiko Aoki(30)f |
Mark Kirk (35)m |
Date of Fire Location |
July 22, 1995 Higashi Sumiyoshi Ward, Osaka |
Dec 3, 1996 Newark, DE |
Victims |
Megumi Aoki (11) f |
Steve Rivera 44 Frances 17(f) Robert 8 |
Suspicions |
1) Common Law Marriage 2) Life Insurance $120,000 3) Korean nationality |
1) evening argument 2) short relationship |
Confession Date + Details |
Sept 10, 1995 Siphoning and igniting gasoline with a tab lighter |
Dec 5, 1996 Pouring Captain Morgan Rum on an electric burner |
Arrest Motives |
compile track records/personal publicity/ racial discrimination |
compile track records Protect apt owner/insurance companies |
Other Problems |
Japan 99.7% conviction rate |
Lawyers presumed guilt, failed to investigate properly. |
Court Decisions |
Life Imprisonment x2 Boku: March '99(District Court) Dec '04 (High Court) Aoki; May '99(District Court) Oct '04 (High Court) |
Oct 97:Three Life Terms+ Feb 04: Felony murder convictions vacated, replaced with manslaughter(44years) |
Present Support Activities |
Both defendants are represented by 6 different attorneys working pro-bono; and 2 citizen support associations. |
Not represented, working pro se |
Recent Developments |
10/'06 Visit of American professional fire Investigator. 05/'06 TV Broadcast "The Scoop." 03/2012 Osaka District Court reopens case! |
06/'06 Forensic Analyst John Lentini performs experiment. |
Solutions |
Reopening of case by court indicates that a reversal is near. |
Publicity/Empowerment (lawyer needed) |
Contact Addresses
Michael H. Fox
Hyogo College
Kakogawa City 675-0195
JAPAN
Michael H. Fox is director of the Japan Innocence and Death Penalty Information Center (www.jiadep.org) and the Network for Innocent Arson Defendants (www.niad.org).
Please feel free to contact either of the defendants by mail.
Tatsuhiro Boku
Hatanaka303
870-8588
Oita City
Japan
Mark Kirk
VCC #291259
1181 Paddock Rd.
Smyrna, DE
19977-9679
USA